BBDO North America: Something Completely Different
Media-Entertainment
Written by Mike Sharkey   
Thursday, 31 January 2008
Cover Story - BBDO: Something Completely Different - American Executive - RedCoat Publishing
How David Lubars transformed traditional ad agency BBDO North America into a new media juggernaut.

In a culture where advertisers cry out for consumer attention in every medium and on every surface imaginable (do we really need those commercial-looping TVs above the john in the men’s room?), the omnipresent pitches are enough to make a person don a tinfoil hat.

Sure, the clever spot here or the gratuitous ad there will entertain, but even then, consumers often fail to make a connection between the pitch and the product. Call it the, “What Was That Ad For?” phenomena.

Cover Story - BBDO North America - Target Ad - American Executive - RedCoat Publishing
The clock was ticking on magician David Blaine as he attempted to escape from this suspended trap in time to make it to Target’s two-day sale. The multimedia BBDO campaign resulted in a spike of 3 million hits on Target’s Web site and an increase in sales of nearly 6%, an all-time high.
And that’s what makes the campaigns created by New York’s BBDO North America so impressive: they not only make it past the blinders, they’re intrinsically linked to their brands.


Take BBDO’s campaign for M&M’s. Colorful TV spots reveal what everyday people would look like if transformed into M&M characters. The ads also serve as an invitation to consumers: join in the fun at BecomeanMM.com and create your own “Inner M” avatar. Within three weeks of the ads airing, more than 2 million people did just that.

BBDO enjoyed similar successes when it invited consumers to become an HBO Voyeur, watch the Gillette Young Guns race, witness magician David Blaine perform an escape for Target, indulge in “One Second Theater” with GE, or see an ordinary street light turn into a giraffe to promote the San Francisco Zoo. By creating non-traditional multi-platform content and events and using traditional media to invite consumers to those events, BBDO struck gold. Shoot, a leading branded content production magazine, confirmed as much when it unanimously named BBDO its 2007 “Agency of the Year.”

David Lubars, BBDO North America chairman and chief creative officer, uses an analogy to describe the innovative approach that’s changing people’s perceptions about advertising and turning the industry on its head: “I’ve always felt that the best guest is the one who is welcome. If you show up in someone’s home unannounced and you’re intruding on them, you’ll annoy them and they won’t like you. When advertisers intrude on consumers, how are they helping people fall in love with a brand? I always want to be the guest that’s invited into your home. Not only that, I want people to come to the parties I’m throwing on behalf of my clients.”

The anatomy of a campaign
Not long ago, BBDO stood as the undisputed king of traditional advertising, with big commercials featuring big stars in big productions for the biggest clients. But at the turn of the millennium, as consumers began spending more time on the Web, fast forwarding through commercials courtesy of Tivo, and getting lost in video game worlds, the Big, Big, Big model began to lose its luster.

Cover Story - BBDO North America - GE Ad - American Executive - RedCoat Publishing
Scene from BBDO’s One Second Theater and Imagination Theater campaigns for GE.
The growing dilemma created a question that began to reverberate throughout the industry: what do we do when traditional advertising just ain’t what it use to be? At the time, the question was more micro than macro for Lubars. As the chief creative officer at mid-sized agency Fallon Worldwide, his BMW client was feeling the early cultural shift away from television more than most.

“The target BMW customer was very sophisticated, into technology, traveling, computer gaming, and they were early Tivo owners,” Lubars said. “Even though the world hadn’t shifted that way yet, BMW’s customer already had, and the folks at BMW realized that. They challenged us to surround the brand in ways that went beyond traditional advertising.”

In response, Lubars’ team came up with BMW Films, a series of suspenseful online shorts directed by some of the world’s most popular directors and featuring the automobile manufacturer’s sleek sedans. It was a completely new advertising strategy and one of the few times in the past decade when the hackneyed phrase “thinking outside the box” truly applies. More importantly, it worked. According to BMW, 2 million people registered with the Web site, the movies were viewed more than 11 million times in four months, and sales in 2001 jumped 12% over 2000.

Lubars, who speaks with the everyman candor of a character from an Elmore Leonard novel, describes the success of BMW Films succinctly: “If you have a great idea, people will love it, celebrate it, and give your client credit for it. People are grateful when you give them something nice instead of the usual shit.”

Dissect the campaign, and you’ll discover the anatomy of Lubars’ creative philosophy. Instead of desperately seeking consumers, create worthwhile content consumers will appreciate and seek out on their own; embrace new media and use it as a tool to reach an audience; and make the campaign as straightforward as its title, as it was with BMW Films. There was no sinister character with a waxed handlebar mustache waiting at the Web site, ready to pounce on consumers yelling, “Ha-ha! You fell into my trap! This is an ad!”

“It’s about total transparency, total honesty,” Lubars said. “We’re not trying to fool people into something they didn’t know they were doing. People know right up front it’s an ad, and they’re still into it. That’s key. I read an article recently where a cell phone company had hot girls go into bars, talk to guys, flirt with them, and then say, ‘Oh, check out my phone.’ To me, that’s the wrong way to go, the bad way on so many levels.”

The right way to go in this daunting new digital world is just what BBDO was looking for. And in 2004, the agency hired Lubars to take it there.

Transformer
Asked to describe the organization when he arrived at BBDO’s Avenue of the Americas offices, Lubars responds in three words: meetings, meetings, meetings. Departments worked in disciplined silos and communicated with one another through an excess of meetings, making work on campaigns cumbersome and more complex than necessary.

But the agency also possessed an abundance of something Lubars was anxious to tap into: creativity. “Thanks to the genius legacy of Phil Dusenberry, creativity was baked into the walls here,” he said, describing Dusenberry, who passed in December, as a visionary. “It was just a matter of directing it forward.”

To direct the creativity forward, the new chief creative officer tore down the silos, did away with the meetings, and began making “a human gumbo where everyone works together in a messy kind of way, but a way that produces results that lift the entire agency higher and higher.” It was a tough sell, and not everyone was buying.

Lubars found the agency split into three factions: those who embraced the new approach, those who abhorred it, and those who were willing to give gumbo a try, but preferred a more traditional dish. BBDO parted ways with those who didn’t want to or couldn’t adapt, and Lubars brought in new technologists, designers, and “left field thinkers who would not have been invited to other ad agencies.”

“We have some of the most brilliant creative people I have ever met,” he said. “They grabbed the wheel, turned it, and helped move the agency in a new direction.”

Cover Story - BBDO North America - Monster Ad - American Executive - RedCoat Publishing
Scene from BBDO’s Monster campaign. Pajama-clad people race uphill with mirrors, umbrellas, and even a satellite dish in hand in a vain effort to stop the sun from rising. “Don’t fight Monday,” Monster tells viewers.
With a new culture and the right people in the right seats on the bus, the BBDO team began working to create campaigns based on the new philosophy—straightforward ads that invited consumers to engage the brand in new ways and across multiple platforms. At BBDO the philosophy became known as TotalWork. To create TotalWork campaigns, Lubars and the account and creative teams leaned on the agency’s behavioral planning researchers and experts to discover each client’s “reductionist nugget.”


“If I said to you, ‘The kid can see dead people,’ you would know exactly what movie I’m talking about even though it came out almost 10 years ago,” Lubars explained. “You can see how that simple idea, the reductionist nugget, spawned an entire two-hour piece. And that’s what we want to do for our clients—strip away all of the artifice to get down to a core, shiny nugget. Because from that nugget we can create what seem to be complicated TotalWork pieces. But they’re based on such a simple, clear idea, that it’s easy for us to launch into new, unexplored territories.”

With HBO, the reductionist nugget was simple: We’re great storytellers. From that seed, BBDO spawned a multi-media campaign that didn’t just tell consumers HBO knew how to spin a yarn, it showed them. Taking a page directly from Alfred Hitchcock’s “Rear Window,” BBDO put consumers in Jimmy Stewart’s wheelchair and allowed them to peer in on the lives of people in a fictional apartment building.

Through TV spots and a massive life-size video projected onto the side of a Manhattan apartment building, BBDO invited consumers to the HBO Web site where they could become voyeurs and watch the lives of 30 tenants in a dozen dwellings unfold through more than three hours of content. Those with the voyeur-jones could also access exclusive content on their cell phones and a movie, “The Watcher,” on HBO On Demand.

Based on site traffic and a major boost in subscribers, the campaign was a success for HBO and a clear demonstration of BBDO’s successful transformation from a traditional advertising agency into a new-media leader. It’s a transformation that has brought with it record-setting results. Working with his partner Andrew Robertson, BBDO Worldwide president and CEO, Lubars and his team have added more than $1 billion in new business each year since 2005, the first full year under Lubars’s North American leadership. And with big names such as AT&T, Best Buy, Monster, and New Balance signing with BBDO this past year, it doesn’t look like the trend will end anytime soon.

Whatever the future may bring, Lubars makes one thing abundantly clear: BBDO will continue to do things differently. “You can’t make ads an intrusion, culture pollution you just can’t stand,” he said. “Unfortunately, there will always be ads that annoy people, but with the quality of talent we have throughout all our offices, I can guarantee you BBDO won’t be making them.”

 
< Previous Story   Next Story >